Folks, I don’t know what to tell y’all here. On the surface, this is far and away the weirdest soda I’ve reviewed. Why did this come to be in existence? Who was the person who came up with this flavor combo? Is it a common flavor combination that I’m just blissfully unaware of? Is there some weird tradition in, like, Macon, GA to put black pepper on peach pie? Either way, this is worth noting: according to the ingredients, there is no actual black pepper in the soda.
It reminds me of the decidedly-less-gross idea of putting salt onto a tomato, but even worse. There’s been a trend recently of combining sweet and spicy things. On the surface, this soda seems to fit into that trend, but… I can’t imagine the soda will be actually spicy, right?
Place of Acquirement: Kroger, Gahanna, OH
Drinking Vessel/Portion: 12oz dark glass bottle
AROMATICS: 8/10
Basically just peach! No Black Pepper scent.
FIRST SIP: 5/10
I am not sure about this. My first instinct says that it’s not super tasty, but this may be a situation where the flavors come out more as it’s drank.
TASTE: 5.5/10
This is really tough. So, first things first, this soda is not dramatic or in your face. I went into it thinking, “oh dear lord, if the soda is spicy, I’m gonna hate it.” In reality, the soda is pretty mild.
AFTERTASTE: 7/10
Nothing too crazy. Pleasant enough, mostly just peach.
MOUTHFEEL: 5/10
Not a great feeling in my mouth. This is a lower carbonation soda, and has a certain texture on top of that. Not unpleasant, but not pleasant.
DEPTH OF FLAVOR: 8/10
It is definitely an interesting flavor! You mostly get the peach, and a sort of general sweetness. The black pepper is very subtle, but there if you look (taste?) for it.
SWEETNESS: 5/10
It’s decently sweet, but definitely not as sweet as your average soda.
FLAVOR(S) TASTED: Peach, lil baby black pepper.
LAST SIP: 6/10
Definitely lost a little bit of carbonation. Still ended up being an enjoyable sip.
OVERALL RATING: 5.5/10
So here’s the thing: I’m probably not going to drink this soda again. That being said, it was still a very interesting experience that I do not regret in any way. By no means did the soda taste how I expected it to taste, but that served it well.
To be completely frank, I expected the soda to be a bit more ambitious than it is. It feels a tad sanitized, like the “Peach and Black Pepper” name is mostly there to grab curious shoppers. Which, to be fair, seems to have succeeded in my case. So yes, it left me a little disappointed, but it *bad*.
